COLORADO NEWS

Top-selling Halloween candy in Colorado over last 17 years is unexpected

Oct 21, 2025, 5:14 PM | Updated: Oct 22, 2025, 12:37 pm

If you or your kids have found a bunch of Hershey Kisses in your loot after trick-or-treating over the years, here’s why…

CandyStore.com reviewed candy purchases from the past 17 years and put together a ranking of the top three candies in every state.  Of course, people buy candy for a lot of reasons throughout the year, so they focused on the months leading up to Halloween.

Although, to me, they’re more of a Valentine’s Day candy, Hershey Kisses were number one in Colorado. Kisses were followed by Milky Way and Twix, respectively.

Here’s the top 10 overall . . . along with the states where it was the top seller:

1.  M&M’s – #1 in: California, Iowa, Kansas, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Vermont, Washington state, and Washington, D.C.

2.  Reese’s Cups – #1 in: Florida, Kentucky, New Hampshire, and Wyoming.

3.  Sour Patch Kids – #1 in: Alaska, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Nebraska, New York, and Texas.

4.  Skittles – #1 in: Alabama.

5.  Starburst – #1 in: Indiana and Michigan.

6.  Hot Tamales – #1 in: Minnesota, New Mexico, and North Dakota.

7.  Candy Corn – #1 in: Our hearts. Kidding. It was #1 in Maryland and Utah.

8.  Hershey Kisses – #1 in: Arizona and Colorado.

9.  Hershey Mini Bars – #1 in: Hawaii, Nevada, Rhode Island, and West Virginia.

10.  Butterfinger – Arkansas, Massachusetts, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Virginia, and Wisconsin.

Outside of the Top 10, Snickers is #1 in Tennessee and Idaho. Jolly Ranchers are #1 in Georgia and South Dakota. Almond Joy is #1 in Connecticut and Missouri. Twix is #1 in Montana. Tootsie Pops are #1 in New Jersey.

3 Musketeers is #1 in Mississippi. Blow Pops are #1 in Ohio, and Lemonheads are #1 in Louisiana.

Colorado News

Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images...

Brian Michel

Denver Pioneers survive epic double-OT thriller, one win away from record 11th national title

It wasn’t pretty. It wasn’t comfortable. At times, it was downright nerve-wracking. But when it was all over Thursday night in Las Vegas, the Denver Pioneers were still standing — […]

3 minutes ago

Greg Penner...

Kevin Kissner

Broncos owners buy 40% stake in Rockies

It’s a crazy time to be a Rockies fan right now. Not only are they playing better than they have in a long time, changes are happening with their ownership […]

2 hours ago

Portillo's...

Shawn Patrick

Is Chicago-favorite Portillo’s still planning to expand into Colorado?

If you’re craving an authentic Chicago-style hot dog or an Italian beef sandwich, you may need to just plan a trip to Illinois at this point… Portillo’s, the Chicago-based fast-casual […]

20 hours ago

(Photo by Justin Edmonds/Getty Images)...

Shawn Patrick

Shirtless Rockies fans go viral as Colorado completes sweep of Astros

The Colorado Rockies have a .500 record for the first time since April 2023 and fans celebrated by taking their shirts off and going viral at Coors Field! The mob […]

20 hours ago

(Photo by RJ Sangosti/MediaNews Group/The Denver Post via Getty Images)...

Shawn Patrick

Eye-sore Wheat Ridge motel where Elvis stayed is being demolished

You’ve likely driven by and seen the sign a thousand times, but soon a notorious Denver-area motel will be nothing but a memory. The American Motel along Interstate 70, that […]

20 hours ago

Photo by Carl Court/Getty Images...

Shawn Patrick

A notoriously haunted mansion in Denver is now available for lease as luxury apartments

If you don’t mind a phantom roommate or two you can now live in one of Denver’s most famous mansions! A notoriously haunted 1880’s mansion in Denver’s Capitol Hill neighborhood […]

21 hours ago

Top-selling Halloween candy in Colorado over last 17 years is unexpected