COLORADO NEWS

Top-selling Halloween candy in Colorado over last 17 years is unexpected

Oct 21, 2025, 5:14 PM | Updated: Oct 22, 2025, 12:37 pm

If you or your kids have found a bunch of Hershey Kisses in your loot after trick-or-treating over the years, here’s why…

CandyStore.com reviewed candy purchases from the past 17 years and put together a ranking of the top three candies in every state.  Of course, people buy candy for a lot of reasons throughout the year, so they focused on the months leading up to Halloween.

Although, to me, they’re more of a Valentine’s Day candy, Hershey Kisses were number one in Colorado. Kisses were followed by Milky Way and Twix, respectively.

Here’s the top 10 overall . . . along with the states where it was the top seller:

1.  M&M’s – #1 in: California, Iowa, Kansas, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Vermont, Washington state, and Washington, D.C.

2.  Reese’s Cups – #1 in: Florida, Kentucky, New Hampshire, and Wyoming.

3.  Sour Patch Kids – #1 in: Alaska, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Nebraska, New York, and Texas.

4.  Skittles – #1 in: Alabama.

5.  Starburst – #1 in: Indiana and Michigan.

6.  Hot Tamales – #1 in: Minnesota, New Mexico, and North Dakota.

7.  Candy Corn – #1 in: Our hearts. Kidding. It was #1 in Maryland and Utah.

8.  Hershey Kisses – #1 in: Arizona and Colorado.

9.  Hershey Mini Bars – #1 in: Hawaii, Nevada, Rhode Island, and West Virginia.

10.  Butterfinger – Arkansas, Massachusetts, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Virginia, and Wisconsin.

Outside of the Top 10, Snickers is #1 in Tennessee and Idaho. Jolly Ranchers are #1 in Georgia and South Dakota. Almond Joy is #1 in Connecticut and Missouri. Twix is #1 in Montana. Tootsie Pops are #1 in New Jersey.

3 Musketeers is #1 in Mississippi. Blow Pops are #1 in Ohio, and Lemonheads are #1 in Louisiana.

Colorado News

(Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images)...

Shawn Patrick

A guy named James Taylor got arrested in Colorado after calling 911 more than a hundred times in a day

James Taylor is a famous folk singer-songwriter, but he does not live in Colorado, and he is not the guy who called 911 over 150 times in one day and […]

17 hours ago

Photo by Jason Kempin/Getty Images for ACM...

Shawn Patrick

Lee Brice announces a Denver tour stop in 2026

The last time Lee Brice headlined a show in Denver was March of 2022 at Mission Ballroom. Finally after more than four years, he is coming back to the Mile […]

18 hours ago

Photo by David McNew/Getty Images...

Shawn Patrick

LOOK – One of Airbnb’s ‘most-loved’ rentals is in Colorado and lets you sleep outside under the stars

Sleeping outside in Colorado wilderness seems like a good way to get eaten by a coyote or bear to me, but it seems as though it’s worth the risk to […]

18 hours ago

(Photo by Getty Images)...

Shawn Patrick

Friendly wild rabbit keeps trying to climb into cars in a Colorado tourist town

My mama always used to tell me that wild animals are cute, but they’re also a good way for you to get some weird disease. I’m not saying this rabbit […]

18 hours ago

(Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)...

Big Mic

New fossils discovered at Colorado Dinosaur National Monument

For the first time in over 100 years, new fossils have been found at Colorado’s Dinosaur National Monument! On September 16, while parking lot construction was taking place at Colorado’s […]

20 hours ago

DENVER, COLORADO - JANUARY 17: Bo Nix #10 of the Denver Broncos celebrates after defeating the Buff...

Brailey Jones

BREAKING: Bo Nix breaks ankle, ruled out for remainder of season

Head Coach Sean Payton initially addressed the media following the game before heading back to the locker room. About 10 minutes later, Payton returned — this time in street clothes […]

4 days ago

Top-selling Halloween candy in Colorado over last 17 years is unexpected