COLORADO NEWS

Top-selling Halloween candy in Colorado over last 17 years is unexpected

Oct 21, 2025, 5:14 PM | Updated: Oct 22, 2025, 12:37 pm

If you or your kids have found a bunch of Hershey Kisses in your loot after trick-or-treating over the years, here’s why…

CandyStore.com reviewed candy purchases from the past 17 years and put together a ranking of the top three candies in every state.  Of course, people buy candy for a lot of reasons throughout the year, so they focused on the months leading up to Halloween.

Although, to me, they’re more of a Valentine’s Day candy, Hershey Kisses were number one in Colorado. Kisses were followed by Milky Way and Twix, respectively.

Here’s the top 10 overall . . . along with the states where it was the top seller:

1.  M&M’s – #1 in: California, Iowa, Kansas, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Vermont, Washington state, and Washington, D.C.

2.  Reese’s Cups – #1 in: Florida, Kentucky, New Hampshire, and Wyoming.

3.  Sour Patch Kids – #1 in: Alaska, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Nebraska, New York, and Texas.

4.  Skittles – #1 in: Alabama.

5.  Starburst – #1 in: Indiana and Michigan.

6.  Hot Tamales – #1 in: Minnesota, New Mexico, and North Dakota.

7.  Candy Corn – #1 in: Our hearts. Kidding. It was #1 in Maryland and Utah.

8.  Hershey Kisses – #1 in: Arizona and Colorado.

9.  Hershey Mini Bars – #1 in: Hawaii, Nevada, Rhode Island, and West Virginia.

10.  Butterfinger – Arkansas, Massachusetts, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Virginia, and Wisconsin.

Outside of the Top 10, Snickers is #1 in Tennessee and Idaho. Jolly Ranchers are #1 in Georgia and South Dakota. Almond Joy is #1 in Connecticut and Missouri. Twix is #1 in Montana. Tootsie Pops are #1 in New Jersey.

3 Musketeers is #1 in Mississippi. Blow Pops are #1 in Ohio, and Lemonheads are #1 in Louisiana.

Colorado News

Photo by Carsten Rehder/picture alliance via Getty Images...

Shawn Patrick

WATCH – Man steals a cop car in Denver, goes for a naked joyride

In today’s edition of “drugs are bad,” someone in Denver had the brilliant idea to steal a cop car and take it on a naked joyride… The Commerce City Police […]

5 hours ago

Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images...

Shawn Patrick

Does Denver have a chance at a white Christmas this year?

2025 may go down as the least Christmas-y year in Denver ever. Record high temperatures have dominated the winter, and we’ve really only had one real snowstorm all winter. But […]

6 hours ago

Star Wars: The Battle For the North Pole...

Shawn Patrick

There’s a ‘Star Wars’ Christmas light display in the Denver-area

If you love Star Wars and Christmas lights, you have to go check out this house in Highlands Ranch, Colorado this season! “Star Wars: The Battle for the North Pole”, […]

7 hours ago

Photo by Roberto Machado Noa/LightRocket via Getty Images...

Shawn Patrick

Christmas lights in Denver stay up through January 25th thanks to the National Western Stock Show

There is always quite a debate on when is the right time to take down your Christmas lights, but that debate is always easily settled in Denver. It’s a Denver […]

7 hours ago

...

Kathie J

Colorado’s favorite Christmas cookie revealed

Colorado likes cake mix cookies! You might not recognize the name, but you will recognize the cookie. Cake mix cookies involve five ingredients and come in lots of flavors – […]

2 days ago

...

Kathie J

Denny’s selling $200 sneakers with real syrup

USA Today says Denny’s is selling $200 limited-edition sneakers that have actual pancake syrup. The yellow, red and brown Sticky Kicks shoes, designed in collaboration with Mache, have clear panels […]

2 days ago

Top-selling Halloween candy in Colorado over last 17 years is unexpected